By BORZOU DARAGAHI
Associated Press
Writer
BAGHDAD, Iraq (AP)--Faced with a freewheeling Iraqi
media, the U.S.-led occupation authority is devising a
code of conduct for the press, drawing protests from
Iraqi journalists who endured censorship under Saddam
Hussein and worry for their newfound freedom.
Coalition officials say the code is not intended to
censor the media, only to stifle intemperate speech that
could incite violence and hinder efforts to build a
civil society. The country is just too fragile for a
journalistic free-for-all, they say.
``There's no room for hateful and destabilizing
messages that will destroy the emerging Iraqi
democracy,'' Mike Furlong, a senior adviser to the
Coalition Provisional Authority, told The Associated
Press. ``All media outlets must be responsible.''
U.S. forces have reason to worry about instability.
Divisions run deep in postwar Iraq, a tribal society
split between majority Shiite Muslims and minority
Sunnis and between Arabs, Kurds and smaller ethnic
groups. Plus there is a thick seam of distaste for the
American occupation.
The issue is also proving another example of the
coordination problems that bedevil the effort to rebuild
Iraq. As coalition officials draw up press regulations,
the U.S. State Department brought together media people
this week in Athens, Greece, to devise a proposed rule
book for Iraqi journalists.
Naheed Mehta, a coalition spokeswoman, said
occupation officials didn't know about the Athens
meeting. Representatives of the Athens group didn't know
about the code being drawn up in Baghdad.
Asked about the unofficial proposal put together in
Athens, Mehta said, ``There's no reason why that can't
feed into our work.''
Coalition officials haven't released details of their
planned code. But, Iraqi journalists, when told of the
idea, worried that it could lead to censorship.
``How can they say we have a democracy?'' demanded
Eshta Jassem Ali Yasseri, 25, editor of the new
satirical weekly Habezbooz. ``That's not democracy. It
sounds like the same old thing.''
Under Saddam, all media were controlled by the
government and anyone who strayed beyond the official
line was punished. But in the weeks since Saddam's
government fell, new newspapers and other media have
sprouted, blanketing the streets with information and
opinions--some of which have called for resistance or
even violence.
``Under America's watch: raping, killing, burning and
looting,'' read a recent headline in Al-Ahrar, a new
semiweekly paper. Another newspaper, Al-Haqiqa, this
week began publishing excerpts of ``The Protocols of the
Elders of Zion''--an anti-Semitic forgery by the Russian
czarist secret police that purported to be a plan for
Jewish domination of the world economy.
Mehta said the Coalition Provisional Authority's
regulations would ban hate messages, including
statements likely to ``incite violence or ethnic or
racial hatred.''
``I'm not going to comment on specifics. They are
still in the discussion phase,'' she said. ``These are
all issues that need to be looked at.''
The Americans already are making clear they are
keeping an eye on Iraqi media.
Editors at the new daily newspaper Al-Manar said U.S.
soldiers turned up at its offices last week to tell them
about a new media monitoring board and ask for their
opinion.
``They plan to set up a committee and some jerks will
be on it,'' said Mohamad Jubar, the editor in chief.
``I'll fight any attempt at censorship.''
Iraq's postwar journalists and politicians say
criticism of authority is at the core of the democratic
ideal.
U.S. officials in Iraq insist there will be no
attempt to block criticism of the occupation.
The Baghdad television station, for instance, which
falls under the coalition's control, has run a number of
stories critical of the U.S.-led occupation. Journalists
there say they're allowed _ and even encouraged--to
criticize the occupation authority responsibly.
One recent report showed footage of U.S. soldiers
grappling with retirees trying to collect pensions.
``We've done some pretty critical stories on U.S.
authorities,'' said Don North, an Arlington, Va.-based
adviser to the station who has helped launch independent
media in the Balkans and eastern Europe.
``The journalists ask, `It is it all right to
criticize the U.S. in our story?''' North said. ``Yes,
of course--if you can substantiate the charges.''
Still, to Iraqi journalists, the idea of a code
evokes years past when media were tightly controlled by
the Ministry of Information and Odai Hussein, Saddam's
son and former head of the Iraqi journalists union.
``Is there a media code of conduct in the U.S. or
U.K.? Why should there be such a thing here?'' asked
Hamid al-Bayati, a leader of the Iran-linked Supreme
Council for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq. Its new
newspaper regularly criticizes the occupation.
Furlong said the coalition would not tolerate
``outside forces spreading destabilizing messages,'' an
apparent reference to Iran, which has flooded airwaves
with radio and television broadcasts critical of the
occupation.
Even some Iraqi journalists wonder if the media
scramble is excessive.
Jubar, the Al-Manar editor, called the current
climate ``a mess,'' and Hamida Smessem, the new dean of
Baghdad University's journalism faculty, said the
unfettered media is too much, too soon.
``These newspapers need to be organized, Smessem
said. ``They're hurting each other with these words.''
___
As U.S.-led occupation officials draw up a code of
conduct for Iraqi media, an international gathering of
legal and media experts working independently in Greece
sketched out its own ideas this week.
Some key proposals:
Adopt media law with penalties, ranging from public
apologies to closure, for defamation, incitement to
violence, hate speech.
Set up council to help draw up code of conduct for
journalists, resolve complaints against media.
Create commission to regulate media, with authority
to allocate radio and TV frequencies, monitor content,
hear complaints. Separate board would hear appeals.
Do not require licenses for newspapers, magazines,
individual journalists.
Grant public and press access to all documents and
decisions of U.S.-led interim governing authority.
Allow private Internet service providers to
operate.
Transform state-owned radio and TV into public
broadcasting system with editorial independence.
Turn government newspapers over to independent,
private owners.
AP-NY-06-04-03 1501EDT
Copyright 2003, The Associated Press.
The information contained in the AP Online news report
may not be published, broadcast or redistributed without
the prior written authority of The Associated
Press.